Here are 20 classic rhyming-type riddles suitable for most fantasy games, in that they do not presume scientific knowledge (such as the moon affecting the tides) or technological advances not every RPG setting has (such as gunpowder or pianos). They also avoid many fantasy tropes, though I'm sure that any standard D&D culture would eventually develop riddles based on healing potions or beholders. Some of them are based on classics of the genre (10, 12, 15, & 17), but all of the rhymes and most of the rest are original to me as far as I know. The solutions are given in the first comment section below. By the way, I've tried to make these pretty easy to solve. Players get nervous enough when faced with a riddle contest; since the stakes in such contests are often high, and the players either get them or not, I tried to make them gettable. If your players genuinely resist solving riddles, however, or are truly bad at it, I suggest filling the riddle-contest area with pictures on stones (featuring a ship, the sun, a horse, etc.) so that players can simply look at 15 or 20 picture options and then touch (or offer to their challenger) the one that fits best. Of course, this limits your answers to concrete nouns or abstract concepts that have standard iconography (such as Death or Justice). Some of these won't work that way. Enjoy!
1. For many it is daily fare,
This drink that no man can prepare.
2. The hour displayed
In stone and shade.
3. I’m hung by my crown;
Fleets stop when I drown
4. I dance with ancient sisters three
But none of them is cold as me.
Beneath us mountains rise and fall
But we never change the dance at all.
5. When a bride sees us coming, her joy disappears
But the man in the garden is glad for our tears.
6. I hold you with feet and back
Though arms I sometimes lack.
7. Feathered, I fly
Landing, I die
What strange bird am I?
8. I come by night
To paint things white
But come the sun
My time is done
9. My light casts no shade
And is nightly displayed.
10. Born black as night,
Next red with heat,
Then cold and white,
My life’s complete.
11. A box that everybody needs in time
But no one wants to use it in their prime.
12. The emptier it gets, the more it grows
As every laborer knows.
13. Rings within rings, but no jeweler has made them;
Soldiers and kings have in battle displayed them.
14. A thousand soldiers guard this golden hoard,
Each with a single sword;
There’s just one door, so theft is quite a feat,
But the reward is sweet.
15. No food I cook will ever fill me
And yet one simple drink will kill me
16. A bottle of future and a bottle of past
Are held in a kiss that holds both of them fast.
When one of them takes, then the other one gives
And then they trade places as long as each lives.
17. The instant my name is spoken
I am broken.
18. My name is not the name my face displays.
That name belongs to one you cannot see.
But we are both engraved in different ways:
Yours truly, and the one who’s under me.
19. My skin is rough and brown.
In spring I wear a crown.
And after fall
I have no hair at all.
20. When someone’s solved my name, I know defeat,
Until that moment, though, I have them beat.
Perfect, exactly what I was looking for!
So simple, so awesome! Thank you for sharing. I'm going to use them in my campaign. Maybe even tonight!
Hi David. I wanted to thank you for these riddles. I stumbled on them on reddit and have been getting some great mileage out of modified versions and just generally have been inspired to make riddles a regular part of my games. I like to integrate them into the mechanism in different ways. Here's an example of how I used your idea for the Chainmail riddle: https://imgur.com/a/J3H0J4u The statue has one hand out with fingers splayed as though you could put a ring on it, and the other hand has a loose grip that might accomodate a polearm. But of course, the trick is to put some chainmail on that sucker.
Thank you. Just what I was looking fpr/
1. MILK
2. SUNDIAL
3. ANCHOR
4. WINTER
5. CLOUDS/RAINCLOUDS
6. CHAIR
7. ARROW
8. FROST/JACK FROST
9. STAR/STARS/STARLIGHT
10. COAL/CHARCOAL
11. COFFIN
12. HOLE (or TUNNEL)
13. CHAINMAIL ARMOR/CHAIN SHIRT(S)
14. HONEY/HONEYCOMB/BEEHIVE
15. FIRE
16. HOURGLASS
17. SILENCE
18. HEADSTONE/GRAVESTONE
19. TREE
20. RIDDLE